Corporate Press Misrepresents State of the Tribes Address as Pro-Mining

By Barbara With, photos by Rebecca Kemble

Even as Jon Greendeer, president of the Ho-Chunk Nation, was delivering a wry but laser-sharp message during the Eighth Annual State of the Tribes address in Madison WI on Tuesday, the corporate press was preparing yet another propaganda story about mining. This time they were fabricating the tribes’ support of it.

Jon Greendeer, president of the Ho-Chunk Nation delivers the State of the Tribes address while members of the sovereign nations look down from the gallery.

With members of the sovereign nations of the eleven Wisconsin Indian Tribes filling the galleries and state legislators looking on, Greendeer began his address with a reminder of what Indian Country stands for: Respect.

“It’s not that difficult to practice, but as you know, it’s hard to find in places where there is discourse and dissension, especially in places where common ground may never be found,” Greendeer said.

In an apparent response to the refusal of the Republicans to recognize the federal treaty rights of the tribes during a slew of recent bills that affect ground water quality and wildlife management, Greendeer stated, “Much time has been spent getting us this far as we try to retrofit the entire state government to be more inclusive of the sovereign tribes, especially on policy and spending that affect our public responsibility to the tribal members and communities we serve. Now the quality of consultation will always be questioned, and perhaps graded, especially when consultation is couched in a foregone conclusion which is to say, if tribal input is without effect or is after-the-fact, consultation has not taken place.”

Leaders of the Wisconsin Indian Tribes. From Left: Stewart Bearhart, (St. Croix) Bob Chicks, (Stockbridge-Munsee) Ed Delgago, (Oneida) Craig Corn, (Menominee) Mike Wiggins, (Bad River Ojibwe) Mic Isham, (Great Lake Indian Fish and Wildlife Commission) Front: Tom Maulson (Lac du Flambeau) and Harold “Gus” Frank, (Forest County Potawatomi) 

On January 26, Republicans in the Assembly locked the public out and illegally passed a version of a mining bill that did not consider the overwhelming sentiment against it expressed at two public hearings. However, the Bad River Band of Lake Superior Chippewa Indians were denied their legal place in the negotiation  in violation of treaty rights that recognize their right to co-manage the natural resources within ceded territories – the northern third portion of the state – that affect their communities.

A proposed 22-mile open pit iron ore mine site in the Penokee Hills would directly impact the Bad River watershed. Geologists testified at a February 17 public hearing that the rock over laying the banded iron formation contains enough sulfide that when it is crushed and added with water, it would produce billions of gallons of acid that would destroy the wild rice fields situated only six miles downstream of the mine. After several versions of the bill failed to pass, Bill Williams of Gogebic Taconite, author of one of the versions, announced that his company was leaving the state because Wisconsin was not “welcoming” enough.  This despite the fact that lawyers for G-Tac drafted the original bill.

President Greendeer reminded the audience that the Wisconsin tribes are already some of the biggest employers in the state and in some counties are the largest employers. They “employ over 13,000 tribal and non-tribal people, with a total payroll approaching 340 million dollars.” And unlike many of the corporations, including G-Tac, who claim to need tax cuts to operate efficiently in Wisconsin, “The tribes collect and remit 97 million dollars in state and federal income taxes.  Tribal purchasing adds another 500 million dollars to local suppliers and vendors, totaling nearly a billion dollars in economic impact to the state.”

So why do non-Native American businesses need to be exempt from contributing taxes in order to succeed here?

In his speech on Tuesday, Greendeer displayed subtlety as he indirectly addressed these issues. “Media continues to hold the monopoly on how complex we make this issue and what we end up discussing at the dinner table. Although the issue is mufti-faceted, the Anishinabeg people haven’t strayed from the central principle; that good caretakers of the land will never find a level of contamination or disregard for sovereign authority worth compromising.”

Oneida elder Warren McLester giving invocation in his language “covering the realm of things and the reason why we are here today.” With Jon Greendeer and Rep. Mary Williams (R), chair of the Jobs Committee that passed AB426 though to the Assembly, and Rep. Jeff Fitzgerald (R-ALEC), who on the night of January 26, ordered observers removed from the gallery and the door locked, and illegally passed through a bill that would have decimated the Bad River Tribe.

True to form, shortly after Greendeer spoke, Associated Press in Wisconsin released a misleading report that was picked up by several local media, including the Beloit Daily News, The LaCrosse Tribune and the Green Bay Press Gazette, claiming, “A Wisconsin tribal leader says he’s optimistic state lawmakers and tribes can move forward on mining legislation.” Statehouse News Online published an article by Ryan Ekvall of Wisconsin Reporter with the headline, “WI’s tribal nations hold out hope for mining compromise.” And the Ashland Daily Press, owned by pro-mining advocates, ran an obviously quickly-written and poorly proofed story, quoting failed Tea Party candidate Shirl LaBarre, and defending DNR Secretary Cathy Sepp (sic. – her name is Stepp) against attacks from her press release last week supporting mining.

This kind of misleading reporting appears to be exactly what Greendeer was referring to. Citizens of the state have been barraged with a continuous stream of pro-mining lies and propaganda which continues to mislead the public on the dangers of mining and overstate the economic benefits of a mine in the Penokee Hills. And yet, even in the face of such irresponsible “reporting,” none of the mining bills have passed through the legislature.

On Monday, March 19, another public hearing will be held at the Capitol on all three versions of the mining bill. Citizens will once again be called to travel from all corners of the state at the last minute to stand up and tell the legislators, again, that mining jobs are not worth destroying the water and the environment of the surrounding communities.

Greendeer articulated the tribes’ united position at the end of his address when he concluded, “Chairman Mike Wiggins of the Bad River, not the Bad Water, said it best that tribes recognize any threats to surface water, ground water, air quality, and our way of life as a call to action. Educating on the effects of mining is less of a struggle than trying to induce a sense of value for our natural world, our mother, our grandmother. The challenge staring us in the face is bringing this value with such little time in the political game.”

The not-so-subtle message Greendeer and the tribes brought was that they are prepared not only to stand united in protecting their rights and the rights of the communities in which they serve, but they will take action to make sure those rights are properly respected and maintained. Thousands of non-native citizens around the state are prepared to do the same in regards to taking action to protect the sovereign nation’s federal treaty rights which are still in full effect in the State of Wisconsin.

Nowhere in Greendeer’s entire address was there any indication that he is “optimistic state lawmakers and tribes can move forward on mining legislation.” This is yet another argument for abandoning mainstream news sources.

Call Associate Press and Statehouse News Online ask them why they would print misleading statements.

Associate Press in Madison
Scott Bauer
Todd Richmond

Statehouse News Online
c/o Franklin Center for Government & Public Integrity
DC Office

127 S. Peyton Street, Suite 200
Alexandria, VA, 22314
Office Phone: 571-384-2090
Meghan Tisinger at

Monday, March 19th
Public Hearing on all three mining bills

Email or phone your legislator and tell them to kill all the mining bills until after the recall.
Find your legislator here.

Watch all of Jon Greendeer’s Address on

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

4 Comments on “Corporate Press Misrepresents State of the Tribes Address as Pro-Mining”

  1. lacuna March 15, 2012 at 9:03 pm #

    tribes recognize any threats to surface water, ground water, air quality, and our way of life as a call to action……yes, because the can:

  2. tedvothjr August 15, 2013 at 1:35 pm #

    Lot’s better than us white folks who lie down and let ‘our’ government for the very wealthy multi-billionaires rape us any way they want to– because they can, Lacuna…


  1. Wisconsin Native Americans present an entirely different view of mining that the corporate controlled press. « Ely Minnesota - March 18, 2012

    […] 15, 2012 by Barbara With in Barbara With, Citizen Media, Environment, Mining and Wetlands with 1 Comment […]

  2. Associated Press Blames Tribes for Walker’s Failed Jobs Agenda | Wisconsin Citizens Media Cooperative - February 14, 2013

    […] a history of mangling the truth when it comes to Native Americans. He is the same journalist who misrepresented the message of the State of the Tribes address by Jon Greendeer in 2012, claiming the Tribes would compromise on the mining issue. AP later […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: